Monthly Archives: January 2012

After SOPA: What Now?


Though I’m sure most of my readers will be familiar with the recent events in the United States legislature, I’m going to spend a brief period discussing it. Skip this part?

In the past month or so, the United States Congress introduced and debated a pair of bills called the “Stop Online Piracy Act” (SOPA) and the “Protect Intellectual Property Act” (PIPA).

Though differently named, they had much the same purpose: To leverage legislative power to increase the stretch of copyright law into the barest workings of the Internet. Essentially, the laws provided for methods by which a company or individual who owned the copyright on material that had been infringed upon by an Internet site could contact the proper authorities, and those authorities would immediately shut down that website. They did this by redirecting traffic to that domain name to a different IP address. These provisions alone promised to break the Internet irreparably. But the further outrages were that no due process was carried out, that the supporters of the bill had received a large amount of money from various film and recording industry lobbyists, and finally that even if you had only linked to a site that had infringing material, you could also be shot down.

These two bills, while having many supporters in Congress, engulfed the Internet in protests by users and site administrators alike. Entire websites took down their content for the day. Other sites “redacted” user content for the day. Many sites showed solidarity for weeks by redacting part of their logos. This was a great day in the history of the Internet, and definitely shows that we have become an entity that is capable of defending itself.

Now, on to the aftermath.


So, now we are past these two awful bills, SOPA and PIPA.

Though they were great threats to our digital freedom, and seems to have been defeated, I have to draw everyone’s attention to one very simple fact about SOPA/PIPA: These bills were not isolated incidents, and they aren’t going to be the last. There are threats to our freedom cropping up in ACTA, in various other copyright legislation, and many other non-governmental places.

But these attacks on our freedom need not go unnoticed, nor do we need to let them happen. We have the power to make a huge difference in our own digital lives, and I’m coming back into the online community to try and impress upon all of you how to do it.

Fixing It

First, since we just spent a lot of time trying to undo a pair of bills that threatened our freedom, let’s try and eradicate the cause. The two really big causes, in this case, are the MPAA (the movie industry) and the RIAA (the recording industry). If we want to do anything to fight against these organizations, we need to seriously look for alternatives. Y Combinator and others have been calling people to arms to try and “replace Hollywood”, but I’m pretty sure that those people are already out there. There are hundreds of people making short films in their basements for absolutely no pay. Try browsing for a while, and tell me that there isn’t something there for you. Then check out the Blender Foundation’s collection of animated shorts! I haven’t heard much talk about the RIAA’s part in this fiasco, but their replacement is already around, too: go to Jamendo and find out that there are some really awesome artists that use Creative Commons to protect their listeners. My favorites right now are Brad Sucks, Tenpenny Joke, and Josh Woodward.

Now, I’ve talked about the major proponents of SOPA/PIPA. But there is an irony in the whole situation that no-one seems to be seeing. While this was going on, and big companies were helping with the protest and censoring their own pages, nobody seemed to realize that those same big companies were guilty of much the same wrongs. Google, Tumblr, Minecraft, and TwitPic? None of these companies affords any freedom to their users! Sure, they let you use their products in limited capacity, but are you able to run a local instance of Tumblr? Can you modify Gmail? Can you even post anything you want on TwitPic? And Minecraft, of course, charges you to use the secret code and never truly lets you in to see it.

Basically what I’m saying is, most of the same people who talk big about digital freedom when it comes to SOPA/PIPA are abysmal at preserving those freedoms when it comes to simple freedoms: The freedom to use (in any way you want), the freedom to copy and distribute copies, the freedom to read and modify the source, and the freedom to redistribute modified copies. Those freedoms, in my life, are just as important as the integrity of DNS.

Now, I’ve talked a lot about digital freedom in a lot of different formats, and if I’ve learned anything it’s this: No one wants to make a drastic change, especially not in this particular area. So my advice is this: Check out the links above. Head over to the Free Software Directory and find something cool that replaces a piece of software you’re using. If you read “Minecraft” earlier and were offended, check out Minetest instead. Don’t replace your entire system with Gentoo just yet–that takes a lot of expertise. But maybe it’s time to use Firefox instead of Chrome? Maybe download LibreOffice to finally replace Microsoft Office? Maybe even brave the switch to Clementine to get away from iTunes! Little, tiny steps like this can really make a big difference in the landscape, and certainly in your perception of free software as being inaccessible or difficult to use.

Another great thing you can do to help in the fight for digital freedom is to join the Free Software Foundation. They’re having a membership drive right now, and they could really use the money. They’ll put it towards making cool software, educating people about it, and pushing for adoption of free formats.

And finally, Internet, I implore you to make one more small step towards freedom: Tell your friends. I don’t care if that translates into pageviews for me (no ads here), but I do care that you spread the word. Start a conversation one day about why everyone uses Office. Ask your graphic designer friends if they’ve tried the GIMP or Inkscape recently. Try not to get too into it–I’ve gone down that road, it’s not pretty–but definitely start to ask people you know about their choices, and if they could make better ones going forward.

Thank you, and go freely.

The Future Under SOPA

A lot of people have been talking about SOPA, the “Stop Online Piracy Act”, which is a bill currently breezing through the US Congress like chicken pox. So, I’m hoping I can shed a little light on what the Internet will look like after SOPA is passed–or at least, my perception of what it will look like.

Intentions vs. Reality

It’s my understanding that SOPA was meant to, well, stop online piracy. The congress seems to think that enacting censorship laws and the like is the perfect way to control what happens on the Internet. They seem to think they have a pretty tight grip over that medium.

In reality, though, an oppressive law–or even a slightly offensive law–has always been easily circumvented by the Internet’s citizens (netizens, as some call them). Consider the recent situations in China, in Libya, in Iran….people don’t sit down and bear it when a government takes an oppressive tack towards the Internet, they stand up and help! Hackers across the world have helped people use proxies and the like to evade firewalls and censorship, but the US Congress thinks that it is different.

But that’s not the only problem with the Congress’ reality. They also appear to think that this law will be a deterrent against piracy. I’m sorry to inform them, however, that the American youth with which I’ve been acquainted are not so easily deterred. Especially when a law is so blatantly unjust, they will not only ignore the law but *actively rail against it* with great fervor. This may not manifest as protests on college campuses, as that era seems to have come and gone, but it will almost certainly manifest in an increased rate of online piracy attempts. If the Congress intends to hurt the web and imprison many well-meaning young people, they have a lot of explaining to do!

Ramifications in Politics

Of course, the practical ramifications as listed above won’t be the only effects. The politicians who support it and vote for it will be voted out of office. It’s not the case that those politicians will be unable to find support–the few people in the MPAA and RIAA will still vote for them, and the portion of Americans who fail to keep up with online news (anyone who only reads the newspaper, for example) will likely not care about the incumbent’s voting record. But any young person, savvy with technology, will undoubtedly step in to not only vote for the challenger, but also campaign feverishly against the incumbent who was so unfair to the web.

Ramifications for Free Software

If the FSF has any sense left, they’ll be jumping on this issue as much as possible. I’d suggest they go on various news channels, to start. They should also make appearances at debates and town hall meetings, to put as much pressure on the candidates as possible. If people associate the FSF with Internet justice, they will likely associate them with digital justice in general. That effect would be a great one for the FSF, which has of late been rather quiet.

Three big things are (hopefully) going to happen very soon: Increased opposition to SOPA, the ousting of its supporters, and the rise of the FSF as a viable political entity. Here’s hoping this year will be a great one for digital freedom.